I'm a Stock Trader

The selloff may be hiding a better story inside it

One position is bleeding. The other is outrunning the market. Both are telling us something.
Scoreboard Update
EXPERIMENT UPDATE — Day 9 System: -3.1% | SPY (same window): -4.1% | Alpha: +1.0% Win rate: 100% (1/1) Open positions: MRK (day 7, -2.4%), GEO (day 3, +6.5%)

Advertisement · Sponsored by Awesomely

NEW LAW: Trump Just Triggered a $382 Trillion Money Migration

While most investors are distracted by shiny objects...
Legendary tech investor Andy Howard has identified a rare economic pattern that's been minting millionaires throughout history.
He calls it a "Commodity Crunch".

Get positioned in Digital Oil before this window closes <<

Today's market and our positions

SPY shed another 1.61% today, closing around $525.18 — and if you were watching the tape in real time, you felt it. Broad selling, very few places to hide. Nine days into tracking this system publicly, the cumulative picture looks like this: system is down 3.1%, SPY is down 4.1% over the same window, which puts us at +1.0% alpha. No trades closed today. Just two open positions doing their thing — each in a very different way.

What our open trades are doing

MRK is the uncomfortable one right now. The Breakout Engine entered at $121.98 seven days ago, and the position is currently sitting at $119.09 — that's -2.37% in the red. Not a fun number to look at. But here's the context that matters: SPY is down 4.18% over that exact same stretch. MRK is holding ground relative to the market, and that's what relative strength in a downtrend actually looks like in practice. It's not winning yet. It's losing less — and in this tape, that distinction is real. We're watching the $118 area closely. That's where the thesis starts to get harder to defend. GEO is telling a completely different story. The Breakout Engine flagged it three days ago at $26.43, and it's now at $28.14 — a gain of +6.47% while SPY dropped 1.87% in the same window. That's +8.34% alpha in three days. GEO has been the kind of setup where the move just kept going after entry, which is exactly what you want from a breakout. Nothing to do here except let it run and watch where it decides to stall.

Today's closed trades, post-mortem

No trades closed today, so there are no post-mortems to run. The scoreboard stays at 1 closed trade, 1 win, 100% win rate — and we'll be the first to say that number gets more meaningful once there are more data points behind it. One trade is a sample size of one. We know that.

What could change by tomorrow's open

What we're watching most closely heading into tomorrow is the broader tape. Sessions like today have a way of producing follow-through — sellers who didn't get out clean often come back the next morning. If SPY opens weak again, MRK is the position under the most pressure. It's already below our entry, and another down gap could push it into stop territory. GEO has more cushion, but a hard risk-off open can pull down even the strongest names, at least temporarily. We're not changing anything overnight — but we're clear-eyed about the setup going in.

What we're watching tomorrow

Tomorrow morning the engines run their full scan — fresh data, fresh setups. Whether they flag something new probably depends a lot on what the overnight futures hand us. If the selling continues, the system tends to stay patient. If there's stabilization, the Breakout Engine and Relative Strength Engine both have names on their watchlists. We'll see what clears the bar.

Advertisement · Sponsored by Investpub

See the details →

See how the system backtests →

How our rebuilt system performs against the S&P 500 in testing — year by year, with the honest caveats.


Keep exploring